Back to search
Data: Q2 FY2025 · Source: SSA Public Data
McGhee, Carl C
TAMPA OHO Trending Up
71.7%
+13.9% vs national avg
What this means for your case: This judge approves cases at 71.7% — well above the national average of 57.8%. Out of 297 decisions, 213 were favorable. Their approval rate has been trending upward over the past 3 years.
Total Decisions
297
Fully Favorable
188
63.3%
Partially Favorable
25
8.4%
Denials
84
28.3%
Total Dispositions
348
Dismissals
51
14.7%
Awards
213
Trend (3yr)
Rising
Decision Breakdown (FY2025)
Fully Fav
Partial
Denied
Fully Favorable: 63.3%Partially Favorable: 8.4%Denied: 28.3%
Approval Rate History
FY2012
71.7%152 dec
FY2013
68.9%415 dec
FY2014
63.9%404 dec
FY2015
61.5%371 dec
FY2017
67.1%362 dec
FY2018
60.9%340 dec
FY2019
68.4%465 dec
FY2020
69.5%446 dec
FY2021
55.3%333 dec
FY2022
64.4%284 dec
FY2023
62.1%272 dec
FY2024
69.6%273 dec
Above national avg Below national avg National avg line
Other Judges at TAMPA OHO (12)
Marzan, Shirley A
363 decisions67.8%
Ballieu, Robert235 decisions67.7%
Zanotti, Barbara J292 decisions65.8%
McIntosh, Melissa J373 decisions65.7%
Craig, Margaret249 decisions61.4%
Slahta, Steven D196 decisions60.7%
Dawkins, John322 decisions56.8%
Vallecillo, Gonzalo114 decisions56.1%
Pierce, Katie H57 decisions54.4%
Kirzner, Ryan296 decisions50.7%
Watkins, Glen H.375 decisions40.3%
Downs, Amber242 decisions31.4%