Back to search
Data: Q2 FY2025 · Source: SSA Public Data
McCaghren, Marni R
MOBILE Stable
59.7%
+1.9% vs national avg
What this means for your case: This judge's 59.7% approval rate is close to the national average of 57.8%. Strong medical evidence and thorough hearing preparation are key.
Total Decisions
288
Fully Favorable
143
49.7%
Partially Favorable
29
10.1%
Denials
116
40.3%
Total Dispositions
351
Dismissals
63
17.9%
Awards
172
Trend (3yr)
Stable
Decision Breakdown (FY2025)
Fully Fav
Partial
Denied
Fully Favorable: 49.7%Partially Favorable: 10.1%Denied: 40.3%
Approval Rate History
FY2010
68.9%411 dec
FY2010
57.0%149 dec
FY2011
63.8%459 dec
FY2012
60.7%417 dec
FY2013
63.5%441 dec
FY2014
64.3%415 dec
FY2015
68.7%387 dec
FY2017
61.9%315 dec
FY2018
63.9%349 dec
FY2019
65.0%414 dec
FY2020
57.9%304 dec
FY2021
66.2%269 dec
FY2022
63.2%228 dec
FY2023
63.0%238 dec
FY2024
59.8%224 dec
Above national avg Below national avg National avg line
Other Judges at MOBILE (10)
Stalley, D B
264 decisions92.8%
Nelson, Roger A254 decisions85.0%
Sheely, Ben E283 decisions84.1%
Muth II, Thomas M283 decisions79.9%
Robinson, Laura L313 decisions75.7%
Guice, Tracy S251 decisions72.1%
Campbell, Daniel S322 decisions66.5%
Murchison, David R183 decisions63.9%
Waller, Robert124 decisions62.9%
Boucher, Kevin309 decisions57.6%