Back to search
Data: Q2 FY2025 · Source: SSA Public Data

Nagle, Kim Soo

SPECIAL REVIEW CADRE Trending Up

57.4%

-0.4% vs national avg

What this means for your case: This judge's 57.4% approval rate is somewhat below the national average of 57.8%. Thorough preparation and strong medical evidence will be especially important. Their approval rate has been trending upward over the past 3 years.

Total Decisions

141

Fully Favorable

48

34.0%

Partially Favorable

33

23.4%

Denials

60

42.6%

Total Dispositions

313

Dismissals

172

55.0%

Awards

81

Trend (3yr)

Rising

Decision Breakdown (FY2025)

Fully Fav
Partial
Denied
Fully Favorable: 34.0%Partially Favorable: 23.4%Denied: 42.6%

Approval Rate History

FY2010
100.0%1 dec
FY2011
25.7%148 dec
FY2011
55.1%234 dec
FY2012
38.0%453 dec
FY2013
34.0%394 dec
FY2014
35.7%311 dec
FY2015
41.2%374 dec
FY2016
42.8%278 dec
FY2017
53.1%96 dec
FY2018
46.7%368 dec
FY2018
0.0%0 dec
FY2018
66.7%3 dec
FY2019
62.5%8 dec
FY2019
60.0%5 dec
FY2019
66.7%12 dec
FY2019
100.0%3 dec
FY2019
42.9%14 dec
FY2019
57.4%54 dec
FY2019
66.7%3 dec
FY2019
46.5%187 dec
FY2019
81.8%22 dec
FY2019
44.4%9 dec
FY2020
58.1%62 dec
FY2020
28.6%7 dec
FY2020
0.0%1 dec
FY2020
100.0%2 dec
FY2020
42.9%7 dec
FY2020
50.0%20 dec
FY2020
34.5%174 dec
FY2020
66.7%3 dec
FY2020
100.0%2 dec
FY2020
16.7%6 dec
FY2021
48.7%199 dec
FY2021
0.0%2 dec
FY2021
50.0%2 dec
FY2021
54.3%105 dec
FY2022
0.0%1 dec
FY2022
56.7%201 dec
FY2023
61.0%136 dec
FY2024
68.8%122 dec
Above national avg Below national avg National avg line

Other Judges at SPECIAL REVIEW CADRE (15)

Smiley, Jennifer
292 decisions75.0%
Weathers, Ena
200 decisions75.0%
Hockensmith, Mark
255 decisions73.7%
Warner, Melissa
245 decisions71.8%
Walter, Nicholas
222 decisions71.2%
Ohanesian, Nicholas M
227 decisions70.9%
Cabotaje, Michael A
91 decisions69.2%
Alden, Randolph W
220 decisions65.0%
Labrum, Robert J
246 decisions63.8%
DiMaggio Wallis, Sandra R
206 decisions63.1%
Day, Kelley
234 decisions57.7%
Fuller, Roxanne
174 decisions56.3%
Eiler, Kathleen H
207 decisions51.7%
Wexler, April M
49 decisions51.0%
Lunderman, MaryAnn
77 decisions49.4%