Back to search
Data: Q2 FY2025 · Source: SSA Public Data
Murchison, David R
MOBILE Trending Up
63.9%
+6.1% vs national avg
What this means for your case: This judge's 63.9% approval rate is close to the national average of 57.8%. Strong medical evidence and thorough hearing preparation are key. Their approval rate has been trending upward over the past 3 years.
Total Decisions
183
Fully Favorable
112
61.2%
Partially Favorable
5
2.7%
Denials
66
36.1%
Total Dispositions
208
Dismissals
25
12.0%
Awards
117
Trend (3yr)
Rising
Decision Breakdown (FY2025)
Fully Fav
Denied
Fully Favorable: 61.2%Partially Favorable: 2.7%Denied: 36.1%
Approval Rate History
FY2010
60.8%452 dec
FY2011
54.6%489 dec
FY2012
59.5%430 dec
FY2013
55.9%472 dec
FY2014
60.0%402 dec
FY2015
67.2%464 dec
FY2017
70.6%364 dec
FY2018
72.6%317 dec
FY2019
64.9%439 dec
FY2020
68.9%389 dec
FY2021
69.0%284 dec
FY2022
62.5%245 dec
FY2023
68.8%221 dec
FY2024
69.4%229 dec
Above national avg Below national avg National avg line
Other Judges at MOBILE (10)
Stalley, D B
264 decisions92.8%
Nelson, Roger A254 decisions85.0%
Sheely, Ben E283 decisions84.1%
Muth II, Thomas M283 decisions79.9%
Robinson, Laura L313 decisions75.7%
Guice, Tracy S251 decisions72.1%
Campbell, Daniel S322 decisions66.5%
Waller, Robert124 decisions62.9%
McCaghren, Marni R288 decisions59.7%
Boucher, Kevin309 decisions57.6%