Data: Q2 FY2025 · Source: SSA Public Data

Hall, Lisa R

PADUCAH Trending Up

45.0%

-12.9% vs national avg

What this means for your case: This judge has a 45.0% approval rate — significantly below the national average of 57.8%. Expect a high bar for evidence. Prepare thoroughly for cross-examination and ensure all medical records are complete. Their approval rate has been trending upward over the past 3 years.

Total Decisions

149

Fully Favorable

60

40.3%

Partially Favorable

7

4.7%

Denials

82

55.0%

Total Dispositions

172

Dismissals

23

13.4%

Awards

67

Trend (3yr)

Rising

Decision Breakdown (FY2025)

Fully Fav

Denied

Fully Favorable: 40.3%Partially Favorable: 4.7%Denied: 55.0%

Approval Rate History

FY2010

55.4%446 dec

FY2011

46.9%507 dec

FY2012

33.3%6 dec

FY2012

47.7%499 dec

FY2013

47.3%423 dec

FY2014

47.9%418 dec

FY2015

51.1%407 dec

FY2017

49.4%391 dec

FY2018

51.1%331 dec

FY2019

47.3%474 dec

FY2020

49.9%409 dec

FY2021

43.0%286 dec

FY2022

41.9%217 dec

FY2023

56.7%275 dec

FY2024

51.0%367 dec

Above national avg Below national avg National avg line

Other Judges at PADUCAH (18)

Thawley, John A

263 decisions90.9%

Messina, Christopher

34 decisions82.4%

191 decisions81.2%

Dixon III, Andrew

214 decisions68.2%

153 decisions65.4%

Selland, R. Dirk

123 decisions63.4%

124 decisions62.9%

De Gruy, Elizabeth

125 decisions56.0%

Satisfield, Renee B

54 decisions55.6%

Turner, Marty S

312 decisions55.4%

329 decisions55.3%

Firestone, Scott C

123 decisions55.3%

Evans, III, George L

35 decisions54.3%

175 decisions46.9%

Ferguson, Jeffrey A

187 decisions46.0%

287 decisions45.6%

Pustizzi, Jennifer

160 decisions45.6%

6 decisions33.3%